Showing posts with label scientific method. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scientific method. Show all posts

Saturday, June 24, 2017

Fear of Vaccines

Why does the notion that vaccines cause autism continue to persist, despite all the scientific evidence to the contrary? In a recent essay, a science writer and father argues that it's all about one of our most basic emotions - fear. According to the author of the article, fear is just too strong an emotion to be overcome by logic or evidence.

If he's right, then continuing to try to convince anti-vaccine advocates with more scientific evidence just isn't going to work. Their fear will have to be acknowledged and addressed. How to do that is a question for which the author doesn't yet have an answer.

Saturday, June 10, 2017

Chondroitin as a Treatment for Osteoarthritis

The dietary supplement chondroitin has been selling for a long time as a treatment for joint pain due to osteoarthritis.  Recently I've even seen advertisements promoting the use of glucosamine/chondroitin (chondroitin is almost always sold in combination with glucosamine) in pets.  I suppose the theory is that if works for humans, then it should work for pets.

And yet, chondroitin hasn't actually been shown convincingly to reduce joint pain (see this blog Oct. 6, 2010).  With that as background, a new study now purports to show that high-quality pharmaceutical-grade chondroitin (not the ordinary over-the-counter stuff) actually does reduce joint pain in people suffering from knee arthritis.  In fact, chondroitin allegedly worked as well as the popular prescription nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, celecoxib.

So chondroitin works, right?  Not so fast. According to the footnotes in the article, the study was sponsored (i.e. funded) by a pharmacy company that makes pharmaceutical-grade chondroitin. It's not hard to imagine that the company has a financial interest in the study's outcome.  The company even provided "editorial assistance" to the author prior to the article's publication.

Putting all that possible bias aside for a moment, the data show a minimal effect of chondroitin at best.  According to Figure 1 in the article, at six months of treatment both chondroitin and celecoxib reduced patients' reported knee pain significantly. However, patients in the placebo group (receiving neither drug) also reported a reduction in pain, by nearly the same amount. In other words, most of the patients' reported pain reduction was caused just by being enrolled in the study and thinking that they might be receiving a drug that worked.

Before I accept that chondroitin definitively reduces the knee pain of arthritis, I'd want to see this study repeated in an independent study.

Saturday, May 28, 2016

ALS and Environmental Pollutants

A recent study raises the possibility that exposure to certain environmental pollutants may contribute to the development of ALS (amyotropic lateral sclerosis, a degenerative nerve disease.) The authors of the study measured the concentrations of more than a hundred specific environmental pollutants in the blood of patients with ALS, using normal persons as controls. They found that the concentrations of some of the pollutants were significantly higher in the blood of patients with ALS than in normal patient controls. The authors concluded that certain environmental pollutants "may represent modifiable ALS disease risk factors."

It's a good study, but we need to be careful not to read too much into it. The data did not prove that environmental pollutants cause ALS. In fact, the data didn't really prove anything at all; they only revealed that an association exists between ALS and environmental pollutants. And as we know, an association does not prove causation. The authors' choice of the word "may" in their conclusion was deliberate and accurate.

And yet, this is still a very important finding because it gives us a possible clue to ALS that could be pursued by future scientific studies. Can the findings in this study be confirmed by other researchers? Are there any animal models that develop neurological conditions similar to ALS, and if so, is their condition made worse by exposure to environmental pollutants under strictly controlled conditions in the laboratory? Do any of these pollutants affect the biochemistry or development of embryonic nerve cells grown under laboratory conditions?

There's a lot more to do before we know for sure whether environmental pollutants contribute to the development of ALS. This current study represents a starting point.

Friday, April 4, 2014

Stem Cell Paper Challenged

Two months ago I reported on an exciting new finding (this blog Feb. 3, 2014) that a Japanese and American team of researchers had developed a simple way to produce pluripotent stem cells from adult cells.   The paper was hailed as a breakthrough of sorts.  If true, it suggested that deriving stem cells from embryos (always controversial) might no longer be necessary.

That finding is now in serious doubt, because other researchers have been unable to verify the data.   A blog site that is following attempts to duplicate the research says that most researchers no longer believe that the findings are real (search STAP cells).   The research institute where the Japanese researchers work is investigating.   So far the original paper has not been retracted, but that’s a distinct possibility.

How can we have any faith in scientific discoveries if the story changes month-to-month?  The answer is that science is not about having faith.   It’s about verifying and then verifying again, until we can have confidence, backed by reproducible data, in what we know.   It’s messy.  Sometimes the answer isn’t what we thought it was, but over time we get closer and closer to the truth, whatever it is.

As for pluripotent stem cells, it’s back to square one when it comes to creating them from adult cells, apparently. Embryos may yet be needed for awhile.

Sunday, October 14, 2012

Journalistic Bias in Science Reporting

How good are newspapers at reporting on follow-up scientific studies on a particular subject, as opposed to focusing only on the initial high-profile hypothesis?

To find out, a team of scientists from France and the U.S. identified the top ten most cited scientific articles published in the 1990s on Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Then they examined the follow-up scientific articles related to each of the ten articles to try to ascertain whether the initial hypotheses in those ten articles had actually stood up to subsequent scientific evaluation. Lastly, they looked at newspaper coverage of both the top ten articles and the follow-up articles. According to the team of scientists, only two of the top ten most cited articles on ADHD were subsequently fully confirmed by other scientific articles. The other eight were either refuted, “strongly attenuated”, or considered unlikely by subsequent scientific articles. This is exactly how good science works; through a continuous process of tests, hypothesis modification, and retests, we come ever closer to the truth, and its not always what it seems at the beginning.

Newspaper coverage of ADHD, however, showed a distinct bias toward the sensational new hypothesis or initial findings, regardless of whether the hypothesis or the findings later proved to be true or not. There were 223 newspaper articles covering the hypotheses and initial findings of the top 10 scientific studies on ADHD in the 1990s. In contrast, there were only 57 newspaper articles covering all 67 scientific follow-up studies, and only one of those newspaper articles reported that a “top 10” paper was being “attenuated” by the newer scientific study’s findings.

No wonder the public is confused. They learn something from the public media one day, and never learn later that our knowledge about the subject has changed through good scientific investigation. Or as the study’s authors put it, “Because newspapers failed to inform the lay public that most initial scientific claims were later refuted or strongly attenuated, they did not reflect the evolution of scientific knowledge."





Monday, June 27, 2011

Reported Side Effects of Prescription Drugs

Have you ever tried to read and understand the entire list of reported side effects (called Adverse Drug Events, or ADEs, by the industry) that comes with your prescription drugs? Or been able to follow the rapid-fire verbal description of possible side effects in a television commercial for a prescription drug?

If you can’t, you’re not alone. An article in the Archives of Internal Medicine reveals that the top 200 prescribed drugs list an average of over 100 ADEs each. Some drugs even have two opposite symptoms, such as diarrhea and constipation, or drowsiness and insomnia, among their possible side effects. That’s because drug companies would rather list all ADEs ever reported by any patient who ever took the drug, than risk a lawsuit later if they are accused of failing to warn the consumer adequately.

In fact, for many ADEs there is insufficient data to support a causal relationship between the drug and the reported ADE. Most of the symptoms attributed to ADEs occur in the general population from time to time anyway. Most of us have had diarrhea, for example, or felt drowsy and “lethargic” at one time or another, even when we were not taking any medications.

It would be nice if drug companies could find a way to separate out the important or frequent side effects from the unimportant or infrequent, without putting themselves at risk for failing to warn consumers adequately. But in our litigious society, this may be hard to do.

Reference: Duke, Jon, et al. A Quantitative Analysis of Adverse Events and “Overwarning” in Drug Labeling. Arch. Int. Med. 171:944-946, 2011.


Friday, October 1, 2010

Texting and Fatal Driving Accidents

Text messages sent per month from hand-held phones increased more than 15-fold from 2002 to 2008. Over the same years the percentage of fatalities in which distracted driving was listed as a possible contributing factor increased from about 12% to nearly 16%.

Based on these data, the authors of a recent report speculate that texting while driving may have contributed to 16,000 additional driving fatalities between 2001 and 2007. The claim was reported in the Los Angeles Times and other papers, but is it true?

There are several problems with this report. First, the authors defined a fatality as caused by driver distraction whenever a distraction was merely listed as present. Other factors such as equipment failure, alcohol, or driver age were not considered. Second, distractions are anything that takes the driver’s attention away from driving, including texting or talking on a hand-held phone, reading an on-board navigation system (also increasingly popular these days), reaching for something, eating, drinking, putting on makeup, etc. Searching for street signs or rubbernecking another accident are also distractions. None of these were factored out in this study.

All the report really shows is that text-messaging volumes (in and out of cars) and the number of fatal accidents due to all distractions are both going up. The authors call it a correlation, but so what? A correlation does not prove causation. I’m reminded of the example presented by my thesis advisor years ago of the tight correlation between the rise in the number of telephones in the U.S. and the decline in the incidence of tuberculosis. Do telephones prevent tuberculosis? Hardly.

Is texting while driving a problem? Probably yes. Does this paper convince me that texting while driving has caused 16,000 additional fatalities? Sadly, no.

Monday, April 27, 2009

Correlation Versus Causation

According to a study of the nearly 140,000 women who were enrolled in the Women’s Health Initiative, women who breast-fed their babies had a lower risk of developing heart disease and diabetes later in life than women who did not breast-feed their babies. The headline of the New York Times article about the research read “Breast-Feeding Benefits Mothers, Study Finds”. Is this a correct summary of the research?

The answer is “NO”! This is a classic case of the common misunderstanding about the relationship between correlation and causation. Yes, there is a clear correlation between breast-feeding and a lower risk of diabetes and heart disease later in life, according to the study. But that is not proof that the act of breast-feeding is what reduces the risk. What if women who breast-fed their children are just more health conscious overall throughout life? What if they exercise more often, or have healthier diets?

A more correct headline would be “Breast-Feeding May Benefit Mothers, Study Suggests”. Indeed, the article itself goes on to say that some experts are cautioning that an association (between breast-feeding and health benefits) does not prove a causal relationship, and that more research would be needed to determine the exact cause of the effect (lower risk).

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

HIV/AIDS Incidence Revised Upward

The number of new HIV infections per year in the United States has been grossly underestimated for the past 20 years, according to an article published in today’s Journal of the American Medical Association (“Estimation of HIV Incidence in the United States.” JAMA 300:520-529, August 6, 2008.) The new estimate for HIV incidence is 56,300 new cases in 2006, 40% higher than previously reported by the CDC. The new data also show that the incidence of HIV has not declined at all since 1991, in sharp contrast to the previously estimated 50% decline since that time (compare Figure 1 in the JAMA article with Figure 9.24 in Human Biology, 5th ed., taken from official CDC data available at the time.) The total number of people living with HIV/AIDS is also expected to be revised upward, but those numbers will not be available until later this year.

How could the numbers have been so far off? For one, the new data are based on better testing methods that more precisely differentiate new HIV infections from long-standing ones. In addition, HIV infection rates are notoriously hard to come by, especially back in time. Even the new estimates are based on extrapolations using data from only 22 states. The CDC does the best it can do with limited data; the rest is an educated estimate.

Officials emphasize that this does not mean that there actually were more new cases of HIV – rather, we now have better estimates of the actual rates of new infection that existed at the time, regardless of whether or not they were accounted for. Nevertheless, some Democrats are criticizing the Bush administration for not doing enough to combat HIV/aids in this country. Senator Waxman of California released a statement last week in which he pointed out that the CDC budget for prevention has actually shrunk by 19% since 2002, and that the president recently requested a reduction in funding for HIV prevention at the CDC. Given that the incidence of HIV has not declined at all over the past 15 years, Senator Waxman may have a valid concern.

Students may react with a "So what are we supposed to believe, when even scientists can't get it right?" attitude. They'll need convincing that this kind of "flip-flop", as it would derisively be labeled in politics, is actually a normal part of a healthy scientific process.

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Why We Believe Anecdotal Evidence

Why do many people persist in believing that certain vaccinations may cause autism, despite the fact that there has never been any scientific evidence to support such a claim? Why is it that we continue to be suckers for all kinds of vague, unsubstantiated health claims for various herbs and food supplements? Michael Shermer, publisher of Skeptic magazine, thinks he’s found a reason. He hypothesizes that our willingness to believe in anecdotal evidence over objective data is hard-wired into our brains as a consequence of evolution. He argues that making a false positive error (believing that "A" leads to "B" when actually it does not) usually has no consequences – if you believe that a fruit is poisonous, choosing not to eat it only leaves you hungry. On the other hand, making a false negative error (failing to believe that "A" leads to "B" when in fact it actually does) can kill you - if you eat a poisonous fruit you may die.

What do you think? Read Mr. Shermer’s one-page opinion column in the August issue of Scientific American (“Wheatgrass Juice and Folk Medicine”, Scientific American August 2008, p. 42) and judge for yourself. This article might be a useful supplement for Chapter 1, Human Biology, 5th ed.

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Gardasil and Irresponsible Journalism

Last Monday the CBS Early Show ran a story about a 14-year-old girl named Jenny who is now nearly completely paralyzed by a degenerative mucle disease of unknown cause. It just so happens that she received Gardasil, the vaccine against human papillomavirus (HPV) 15 months ago, like so many other girls her age. Her parents spoke to CBS News with the hope that coverage of Jenny’s plight would help them find “comparables” - other patients with the same symptoms, so that her doctors could discern the actual cause of her disease. Nevertheless, CBS chose to run the online story with the more sensationalist headline, “HPV Vaccine Linked to Teen’s Paralysis?” (CBSNews.com, July 7).

Four days later, FOX news went one step further with a story entitled “HPV Vaccine Blamed for Teen’s Paralysis” (foxnews.com, July 11).

This is biased journalism at its worst. Who exactly is blaming Gardasil for Jenny’s disease - Fox News? In fact the Fox News article is full of errors. For one, the article attributes to Jenny’s parents a statement made by a spokesperson for Merck, Gardasil’s manufacturer. In addition, the article uses the word “casually” in place of “causally”. For the record, what a Merck spokesperson actually said was, “We’re aware of this case and based on the facts that we’ve received, the information doesn’t suggest that this event was causally associated with vaccination.”

On their blog site on July 7 (see www.jenjensfamily.blogspot.com), the parents expressed disappointment with the CBS news coverage, saying “The family believes that there may be a link between Jenny’s health and the HPV vaccination……” “But, there is no medical consensus on whether this hypothesis is stronger than other possible explanations.”

Jenny’s parents are obviously scientifically literate. They know how to distinguish between a hypothesis and a scientifically justifiable conclusion. As you’re discussing the importance of being scientifically literate in your classroom, Jenny’s parents’ blog site and the two news articles would make interesting topics for discussion.

One final thought: Do you think that the biased news coverage of Gardasil could be intentional, given that conservatives don’t like the idea of a vaccine against a sexually transmitted disease being given to young girls? What do your students think?

Friday, June 27, 2008

Cell Phones and Brain Cancer

It happens over and over. First, someone says (again) that cell phones may cause brain cancer. Then the FDA reports that there is no convincing evidence that cell phones are a health risk. (See “Experts Revive Debate Over Cellphones and Cancer”, The New York Times online, June 3, 2008.) What’s a consumer to believe?

This is a good example of the limitations of the scientific method, and why it is sometimes hard to know the truth. Regarding the first statement, yes, cell phones may cause brain cancer (and then again, they may not.) As for the second statement, it is true that there is still no scientifically convincing evidence that cell phones are a health risk. (But again, that doesn’t mean they aren’t!)

Why is it so hard to find the truth? First, brain cancers are so rare that one would have to study literally hundreds of thousands of people. Second, to do the scientific study properly, a controlled study would need to be done in which the lives of hundreds of thousands of people would have to be strictly controlled. It can’t be done. Third, no one has used cell phones for 50 years, so potential long-term effects won’t show up for awhile. And fourth, modern phones emit much less energy than the older models did.

What can we do? We can study those few patients with brain cancer and ask questions – questions about health habits, including past cell phone use. Self-reports by patients are notoriously unreliable, of course, so it may take hundreds of such studies before we consider the evidence “convincing”. We don’t need to panic, but we need to be watchful of the changing state of knowledge regarding cell phones and cancer.

Incidentally, a similar question came up in the 1950s when smoking was actively encouraged – does smoking cause lung cancer? Who could have known that nearly sixty years later the rates of lung cancer in persons over 65 would be more than five times the rates of that same age group in 1950?! However, this does not imply in any way that the same sort of outcome is inevitable for cell phones. They're totally different issues.

Monday, May 5, 2008

Texas Blocks 'Creation Science' Master's Degree

The Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board voted unanimously last month not allow the Institute for Creation Research (ICR) to grant online Master of Science degrees in science education. The ICR makes no secret of the fact that it supports a literal interpretation of the Bible, including the creation of Earth in six days.

“Religious belief is not science,” said the state’s commissioner of Higher education in recommending to the board that they disallow the ICR application. He added, “Science and religious belief are surely reconcilable, but they are not the same thing.”

Thursday, January 3, 2008

The Limits of Science

The free online version of the New York Times has a recent article that could be used to start a discussion in your Human Biology classroom about the limits of science. (“Both Sides Cite Science to Address Altered Corn”, Dec. 26, 2007, nytimes.com). In this case, Europeans are arguing over whether or not to ban the planting of a pest-resistant strain of genetically modified (GM) corn.

Interestingly, both sides are trying to justify their position on the basis of science. Those opposing the planting of the GM corn argue that one can never be absolutely certain that the new corn is completely safe. They are right, of course; science cannot absolutely prove GM corn’s safety under all known (and as yet unknown!) conditions. On the other hand, those in favor of planting the GM corn argue that according to the currently available scientific evidence, GM corn is “unlikely” to pose a significant risk. They are right, too.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to ban GM corn will be a public policy decision based not only on the available scientific data, but also on political, economic, and social pressures. Nevertheless, science certainly does have an important role in issues such as this. Points of concern raised during public debate can perhaps be tested by science, improving our confidence in public policy decisions both now and in the future.